GitHubMeanwhile, on GitHub...

Wrestling with Code

So, you're diving into modern web development with React, Next.js, or similar frameworks? Let's talk about how we can take Uncle Bob's clean code principles and make them work in today's landscape. No theoretical fluff—just practical approaches that work in real projects.

Introduction

While Robert C. Martin's Clean Code principles have stood the test of time, the landscape of web development has evolved dramatically. Today's applications are built with sophisticated frameworks like React, Vue, and Angular, running on both client and server through frameworks like Next.js and Nuxt. Let's explore how we can adapt clean code principles for modern web architecture.

The New Face of Separation of Concerns

Remember when separation of concerns meant simply splitting your HTML, CSS, and JavaScript? Those days are long gone. In today's component-based world, we need to think differently about how we separate our code.

What This Looks Like in Practice:

  • Components That Know Their Place: Your React components shouldn't be doing everything. A common mistake is stuffing authentication, data fetching, and business logic all into one component. Instead, break it down:
    • UI Components: Focus purely on presentation
    • Custom Hooks: Handle your business logic
    • Context: Manage your application state
    • API Layer: Deal with data fetching

For example, instead of this:

function UserProfile() {
  const [user, setUser] = useState(null);
  // 50 lines of messy data fetching and business logic
  return <div>{/* Complicated UI code */}</div>;
}

You might break it down like this:

function UserProfile() {
  const { user, updateUser } = useUser();
  const { preferences } = useUserPreferences();

  return (
    <UserProfileView
      user={user}
      preferences={preferences}
      onUpdate={updateUser}
    />
  );
}

Much cleaner, right?

Dependency Injection: Still A Powerful Tool, but..

Forget everything you learned about traditional dependency injection—we've got something better now. React's Context and custom hooks give us a more flexible way to handle dependencies.

The Modern Way:

  • Use Context for app-wide dependencies (think authentication, theme, or API clients)
  • Create custom hooks for feature-specific dependencies
  • Keep your components focused on what they're good at—rendering UI

Here's a real-world example of how this might look:

  • Your authentication context handles user sessions
  • Custom hooks manage specific features
  • Components stay lean and focused

Scaling Your Application

Let's talk about something that keeps many developers up at night: how do you scale your application without turning it into a maintenance nightmare?

Smart Scaling Strategies:

  • Start Simple: Begin with React's useState and useReducer. Don't jump to Redux just because everyone else is using it.
  • Add Complexity When Needed: Watch for these signs that you need more robust state management:
    • Multiple components need the same data
    • State updates are becoming complex
    • Performance is suffering
    • Your team is growing

The Art of Delayed Decision Making

One of the best pieces of advice from Clean Code is about delayed decision making. In modern web development, this is more relevant than ever.

What to Consider:

  • State Management: Start with local state, move to Context, then consider third-party solutions only when needed
  • Data Fetching: Begin with simple fetch calls, then evaluate solutions like React Query or SWR based on your needs
  • Styling: Start with CSS Modules or styled-components, assess if you need a UI library later

The Power of Simplicity

The principle of simplicity is even more crucial in modern web development. With so many tools and libraries available, it's tempting to over-engineer solutions.

How to Stay Simple:

  • Resist the urge to add libraries for small problems
  • Use built-in React features when possible
  • Keep your component hierarchy shallow
  • Split code into small, focused pieces

The TypeScript Factor

While Uncle Bob didn't write about TypeScript, it's become a crucial tool for maintaining clean code in modern web applications. Here's how to use it effectively:

  • Start with basic types and interfaces
  • Use TypeScript to document your code's intent
  • Let the type system catch errors early
  • Don't over-complicate your types

The Bottom Line

Clean code in modern web development isn't about following a strict set of rules—it's about finding the right balance for your project. Start simple, add complexity only when needed, and always keep maintainability in mind.

Remember: the best code isn't the most clever or the most concise—it's the code that your team can understand and maintain six months from now.

What's Next?

As you build your next feature or start your next project, try applying these principles. You might be surprised at how much cleaner and more maintainable your code becomes when you adapt these time-tested principles to modern web development.

And hey, if you're wondering about how to implement any of these patterns in your specific case, feel free to start small. Clean code is a journey, not a destination.

Stay tuned for Chapter 12: Emergence.

Read More